Delicious dish

Restaurants may come and go, but a good meal, fine atmosphere and welcoming service can transcend decades.

By Phyllis Stein-Novack
Add Comment Add Comment | Comments: 27 | Posted Oct. 13, 2005

Share this Story:

I tend to wax nostalgic whenever I think of restaurants long gone. They were the places of my childhood, places where I learned about good manners and tasted many different foods for the first time.

Palumbo's is the most famous shuttered restaurant in South Philadelphia. It was more than a restaurant. It was a showplace for Italian food, movie stars and entertainers. Owner Frank Palumbo presented the finest entertainers in the country, including Frank Sinatra, Tony Bennett and Dean Martin.

It was the place my husband, Edward, sipped his first martini at age 21. The food was pure Italian American and Palumbo's heyday was before the Italian food revolution. So, let's talk pasta. Of course, it wasn't called pasta then. It was spaghetti or macaroni.

Palumbo's spaghetti and meatballs were famous -- so famous there's a classic photo that ran in newspapers throughout the country -- and is even on this page -- of the two Franks, Palumbo and Sinatra, tucking into a bowl. You could order ravioli or lasagna, all covered in homemade gravy. Mussels arrived in homemade gravy, as well. Veal parm, chicken parm or a thick steak rounded out dinners.

I recall two other Italian restaurants that have disappeared: Tarello's on the 1600 block of Chestnut Street and DaVinci's on Walnut Street, which is now the home of the Irish Pub.

My family or friends and I would often enjoy dinner at Tarello's after catching a movie at the now torn down Fox Theater. Tarello's had a colorful mosaic of a bull and matador at the entrance. I could never understand this salute to Spain because the food was pure Italian. Tarello's was slightly dark inside; I guess the owners thought it made for a romantic atmosphere. Like Palumbo's, Tarello's served Italian-American food.

DaVinci's was more kitschy. The entrance and interior had

knock-offs of Da Vinci and Michelangelo artworks. The tables were covered in red- and-white checked cloths that, during the '50s and '60s, meant you were dining in a "real" Italian restaurant. It was at DaVinci's that I tasted my first lasagna.

Sometimes memory plays funny tricks on us. I can't remember whether Philadelphia had a Schraft's restaurant, but I do remember Stouffer's. Today, Stouffer's is known for its Lean Cuisine, spinach soufflé and macaroni and cheese. But when I was a girl, Stouffer's was a genteel place where ladies wearing suits, gloves and hats lunched on dainty fare. There were two locations -- one on Chestnut Street and one near the now-shuttered ice-skating rink at Penn Center. (Oh, do I miss that skating rink!)

Stouffer's offered American food, like chicken a la king, Waldorf salad, tea sandwiches, creamy homemade soups, chicken pot pies and, for dessert, hot fudge sundaes.

The Pub was just steps away from Stouffer's on Chestnut. The location now houses a clothing store, but the tiled "welcome mat" at the door still says "The Pub." At lunchtime, my friends and I loved their burgers and hot brisket sandwiches on rye topped with gravy.

Then there was the Pub Tiki. Talk about kitsch. The place was on the corner of 18th and Walnut streets at the entrance to Rittenhouse Square. It was a Polynesian nightmare inside with over-the-top atmosphere, as if a person wanted to recreate "Mutiny on the Bounty" indoors. Drinks were served in carved ceramic tiki glasses complete with small colorful paper umbrellas. We shared the infamous pu pu platter, a large round plate with a sterno in the center in which you "cooked" already cooked food, such as miniature egg rolls, spareribs, chicken and pineapple on wooden skewers and chicken livers wrapped in bacon. Although the food was sort of Chinese, the addition of cherries and pineapples made it "Polynesian." Fruit was tossed into any stir fry from chicken to shrimp.

Whenever I think of burgers, The Harvey House immediately springs to mind. It was on South Broad Street, near the then-Shubert Theatre, now the Merriam. The Harvey House was open for lunch, dinner and late-night supper. I can still see the wooden booths lining the wall in the backroom. I can still taste the famous Harvey burger, topped with grilled bacon and cheddar cheese. The ice cream sodas and milkshakes were second to none.

STEAKHOUSES WERE BIG when I was growing up. Frankie Bradley's on Juniper Street was famous for its rib steak with garlic served on a plank. It drew politicians for lunch and dinner who went to eat and be seen. Arthur's Steak House on Walnut Street, where Susanna Foo Chinese Cuisine is now, was more upscale and formal than Frankie Bradley's. Arthur's always served voluptuous oysters.

Kelly's on Mole Street, owned and operated by Sam Mink, was famous for its raw bar and fresh fish. His son David later opened the Sansom Street Oyster House in 1976. To me, the latter still serves the finest cherrystone clams and oysters in the city.

But I really miss Horn & Hardart. It was the original fast-food emporium -- the automat. You were given a handful of nickels, you placed them in a slot, opened a glass door and pulled out sandwiches, salads, cakes and pies. Hot food was served from a steam table and contained everything from the best Salisbury steak I have ever eaten -- and today no one can make it taste like Horn & Hardart's -- to creamed spinach, macaroni and cheese, Harvard beets, whipped turnips and homemade baked beans, piping hot in their brown ceramic ramekins, topped with a slice of crisp bacon. The coconut custard pie floods me with memories as does the vanilla cupcakes topped with a rich thick chocolate frosting.

I enjoyed Chinese food at Harry Chin's in Chinatown and the Cathay Tea Garden on Chestnut Street, right near the John Wanamaker store, which is now Lord & Taylor. Harry was a friendly guy who always doted on me and my sister. He always brought us a Shirley Temple topped with a paper umbrella. These were the days when you ordered from Column A and Column B. Won-ton soup, egg rolls, chicken chow mein, shrimp in lobster sauce, chocolate

ice cream and fortune cookies were theorder of the day.

The Cathay Tea Garden opened duringthe 1920s and I believe it was once a speakeasy, but I'm not sure. My mom Berthe, who is 90, would go to lunch there with friends. My friends and I would lunch there as well, until it closed in the 1960s. The funniest thing about this place -- it was a Chinese restaurant that served a loaf of Italian bread to all its customers.

Page: 1 2 |Next
Add to favoritesAdd to Favorites PrintPrint Send to friendSend to Friend


Comments 1 - 27 of 27
Report Violation

1. Stafford J. Keer said... on Jun 24, 2010 at 01:03PM

“Your article brings back my childhood memories of the Mole St. restaurants.
Mrs Kelly had the larger and more known place. My Grandmother Lena Keer had the last of several Keer restaurants at 17 S. Mole and across the street was Wagner's. When I visited my grandmother;s restaurant on Sundays I would often walk by Mrs Kelly's and many times she and I would have a chat. She was a friendly woman. My grandmother had a contract to feed the juries and prisoners in City Hall. After 50 years the Keer restaurants went out of business in 1941.”

Report Violation

2. Helen said... on Oct 16, 2010 at 09:22AM

“Since this review was posted back in 2005, by Phyllis Stein Novak, I wonder if she is still living. I loved her article about so many Philadelphia Restaurants that we visited, growing up in Philadelphia 60 yrs ago, or longer, since I am 78 now. Bookbinders, Cathay Tea Gardens, Turin Grotto and Tarello's with Victor Tarello there to greet us, and yes, the Hunt Room and yes, I remember Schraft's and Stouffer's on Chestnut Street and Child's up around Broad and Chestnut Sts, then there was Whitmans Chocolates further up on Chestnut around 16th that had a lunch counter in the back where we often grabbed lunch before going to the Boyd or the Aldine Theater to see a movie..... and yes, The Harvey House too down near the Schubert Theater........... and the .Horn and Hardarts automat was
always a treat too. I haven't lived in the Philadelphia area for over 45 yrs, but still have family there. Sure are lots of changes......Thanks for all of these sentimental memories.”

Report Violation

3. Joe Kullman said... on Sep 13, 2011 at 01:36PM

“I remember most of these places, but one of my favorites was the Turin Grotto On 13th St. I believe. It was plain & simple & not too expensive. I especially recall the spaghetti & meatballs, & would love to get the recipe for their sauce, which I can still remember, but unable to duplicate.”

Report Violation

4. Linda said... on Sep 23, 2011 at 05:43PM

“This wonderful piece written by Ms. Stein Novak was such a pleasure for a former Philadelphian. I remember Schraft's as a child with my grandmother, who would take me after the movies for a dish of ice cream served in paper liners fitted in stainless holders. I remember Stouffer's for lunch when I worked my first job for Bell Telephone of PA, located on the Parkway a block or so away from Penn Center. When I was a 13 year old girl, after a slumber party we young teens would take the train into the city and eventually wind up at the Pub Tiki at 2 on a Saturday and sit in the back of the bar, ordering a PuPu platter for all of us! How in the world did they tolerate that! As an older teen, we drove in from the suburbs late on a Saturday night to The Harvey House, where I enjoyed my first 'Reuben' sandwich. This piece brought back such wonderful memories. Thank you.”

Report Violation

5. Dan said... on Oct 9, 2011 at 04:13PM

“The Turin Grotto at 13 N 13th St. was owned by my grandparents, Biagio and Stamura Amadio. The recipe for the sauce was my grandmother's. Great food and affordable. Still have a menu from the 60's framed in our home. My grandmother was the heart and soul of the place. She passed on and my grandfather gave it a go for a number of years, but the Market St. East area was starting to decay. He finally sold and enjoyed retirement after working so hard for 40 years in the same location.”

Report Violation

6. Anonymous said... on Oct 25, 2011 at 09:17PM

“My parents met at the Cathay Tea Garden at a dance in 1938.”

Report Violation

7. Agnes said... on Mar 16, 2012 at 02:09PM

“Loved reading about favorite childhood restaurants and would love the Horn and Hardart's chow mien recipe. Anyone have it?”

Report Violation

8. howard said... on Mar 27, 2012 at 11:36AM

Can you look at your framed menu and check the street location? I have a sense that Turin Grotto was located on the north side of Chestnut Street, maybe between 12th and 13th. It was in the basement, I recall, and the Cathay Garden occupied the second floor. I can't remember the retail store that occupied street level, though.”

Report Violation

9. Dan said... on May 27, 2012 at 08:08PM

“There were two Turin Grotto's . My grandfather and his partner Cesar Guala owned both and then they split the ownership/management. My grandfather kept the one located a 13 N 13th ST. near City Hall etc. Cesar had the other one which was right on Chestnut St. Both were great places to eat authentic and reasonably-priced Italian food.”

Report Violation

10. Jo-Ann Miller said... on Sep 20, 2012 at 11:16PM

“I worked as a cashier at 1221 for my Grandpop, Carlo Merletti.
Guido & Francis Maggi were owners at that time. I am now retired and would love to have photos or even info about the upstairs (Cathey Tea Gardens) and my beloved Turin Grotto. Thanks.”

Report Violation

11. Francis said... on Mar 21, 2013 at 11:33PM

“Getting back to Palumbo's, I had the privelege of seein the Mills Brother's there. There were three living at the time. One of them came out to the bar and my father had a beer with him. Silvy was the bartender who arranged it. It made my father's day.”

Report Violation

12. Agnes said... on Dec 16, 2013 at 09:11PM

“Does anyone have the recipe for the Chow Mein at Horn and Hardart or Lit Brothers in Philadelphia? Really miss it. Closest is Chen's in Westerly Rhode Island. Anyone have that recipe? Getting to far for me to go there anymore but I could make it. Thanks for any help you can give me.”

Report Violation

13. herb hantman said... on Jan 29, 2014 at 01:11PM

“I remember all the restaurant you mentioned But how can you leave out Linton's where your food came to you on a conveyor belt. And please let me add Shoyers on Arch Street, Ralph's on 9th Street. Maurices on Quence Street where us intellectual teens used to eat hamburgers and listen to classical music. Actually there is no end to the list of great gone forever restaurants in Philly so I must stop myself from going on...Herb Hantman”

Report Violation

14. phil said... on Mar 28, 2014 at 03:55PM

“Turin Grotto wow what memories and it is funny now because they actually gave out little blotters, I found one in my desk and that is what made me search their name. Superb food Thanks for the memories of all those great food places. I also remember the Hanscum (?) bakery stores. Their birthday cakes were #1.”

Report Violation

15. Agnes said... on Oct 11, 2014 at 06:35PM

“do you have the recipe for Lit a brothers Chow Mein. It is the same as Horn and Hardarts too I think. Been trying to get it for years only one place I know makes it that way and it is in Rhode Island in Westerly at Chens Village on Route 1. If you can get it I would greatly appreciate it. Thanks”

Report Violation

16. bruno gallia said... on Oct 26, 2014 at 09:57PM

“I just came cross this site and was thrilled when the Turin Grotto was mentioned. I knew both sites as Dan points out. Dan's mother Madeline was my Godmother. She was the daughter of Biagio and Stamura of the 13th St. location. Cesar Guala who ran the Chestnut St. location was my Godfather. His wife was Rose. They introduced my father when he arrived from Torino, to my mother. They were wonderful restaurants with their good Italian food. Attended many a wedding and parties there years ago. Wonderful memories”

Report Violation

17. bruno gallia said... on Oct 27, 2014 at 10:18AM

“As far as Palumbo's, it was a wonderful Phila. landmark restaurant with some of the best entertainers ever available. Also upstairs was the CR club which was private and needed membership. The Palumbos, all of them, were friends of my family as well as the Amadio's and Guala's from the Turin Grotto. One of the Palumbo's establishments was the "CLICK". In the 40"s it was one of the best night clubs in the country.”

Report Violation

18. bruno gallia said... on Oct 29, 2014 at 05:33PM

“I also remember Maurice"s on Quincey St. Quincey was more like an alley, somewhat underlit which started the subdued excitement young, even underaged, people experienced entering the place. After entering one experienced the musty but non offensive smell which added to the almost errie atmosphere of the room. I believe the sandwhiches were named after famous colonial individuals. We went there in the late 50's early 60's. We really enjoyed going there for some good food and "easy" drinks.”

Report Violation

19. Kitty M. said... on Dec 13, 2014 at 03:18PM

“I just discovered this website ( : searching for H&H recipes. OMG reading these posts brought back so many memories almost tears ( ; I've lived in S. Calif. most of my adult life an many times missed especially the Chinese food at South China on 9th? Street. But really all the food in Philly was better ( :

Through the internet I've discovered my favorite dining partner passed away several years ago. We had several places we went to over and over again. At H&H she would always have the roast chicken - but I was hooked from childhood on Harvard beets, their spaghetti and the coconut custard pie. We loved the Cathay Tea Garden, I can still see that stairway. It was kind of a mysterious place. If I remember a host would be at the top of the stairs and we'd ask for a table overlooking Chestnut Street.
Another favorite of ours no one has mentioned was DaVinci's up by Rittenhouse Square. It was almost directly across from the Wanamaker mansion and it was in the basement. The lasagna”

Report Violation

20. Lynn said... on Jan 3, 2015 at 09:02PM

“Bruno thanks for sharing your memories of the Tourin Grotto. Madeline the daughter of Biagio and Stamura Amadio of the Turin Grotto is my mother. I remember she spoke often of Bruno Gallia and how as a little boy he could identify every car in the road.”

Report Violation

21. bruno gallia said... on Jan 8, 2015 at 09:39AM

“Hi Lynn, I am thrilled to hear from you. I remember you as a little girl running around your living room on Keystone ave. We lived a block away on the corner of Keystone and Beverly Blvd. Your mom would have me to dinner sometimes (loved her artichokes) and of course your dad was our dentist for years. When you mentioned the car thing you jogged my mind for many sweet memories of your entire family. I spent many hours with Stamura. Dan and I ran into each other on another "school" site (St. Laurence) a few years ago. I think of your mom often and could go on and on with years worth of wonderful memories. XO.”

Report Violation

22. bruno gallia said... on Jan 8, 2015 at 02:07PM

“Lynn, the more I think about it, you may be the only one who remembers or knows about the cars now days. My daughter does not know. I think it's remarkable you remember this even though your mom told you. I know Dan is in Florida, are you anywhere close to the Phila. area?”

Report Violation

23. Anonymous said... on Mar 18, 2015 at 12:32PM

“I fondly remember going to Arthur's (in black tie) with dates before formal dances at Penn. A real classy place, they gave you a dime if you called in a reservation. This was mid-sixties.”

Report Violation

24. CAMILLE DEGREGORIO MCCOLGAN said... on Apr 30, 2015 at 11:12AM


Report Violation

25. Len said... on May 23, 2015 at 11:19AM

“Wonderful memories. How about PlumbosNostalgia, Victors where the waiters served opera with your meal, the Latin Cosino, Dante and Luigis, Jack Urs and the Colonial, Villa d Roma where Cus was the chef, and all the others mentioned. Those were the days my friend. We thought they'd never end but now they exist only in our memories.”

Report Violation

26. Dan said... on Nov 4, 2015 at 03:49AM

“Kellys on mole st., Arthurs Steakhouse, Stouffers, even the Harvey House both Bookbinders Iremember as a very young-5-6 year old. But my favorite was when my grandmother took me to tea at the crystal room at Wanamakers -

Report Violation

27. Mike B. said... on Jan 18, 2016 at 11:31PM

“Thanks for posting these memory's, which brings me back to colorful evenings at a center city coffee house " The Artist Hut" at 20th. and Walnut or the Bird Cage on 21st. and Samson. What great places to meat girls and guys from all parts of the city and surrounding areas. The Hut was a dark basement grotto that served espresso and coffee, steeped in atmosphere and dark excitement who will I see, who will I meet. Always bumped into plenty of friends from South Phila. 1964 was a great year. The following year it was off to City Line Ave. and some wonderful experiences.”


(HTML and URLs prohibited)