Anastasi Seafood

By Phyllis Stein-Novack
Add Comment Add Comment | Comments: 1 | Posted Aug. 7, 2014

Share this Story:

A trip to Anastasi Seafood, which is located in the heart of the Italian Market, should be added to the summertime must-do list.

Photo by Corey Carter

On a brutally hot July day two years ago, I brewed some iced tea and settled in to watch Anthony Bourdain tour the Hudson River Valley. He sat on the banks of the Hudson River and enjoyed hard-shell crabs and beer with local men who set crab traps in the river. I never knew hard-shells thrive in the Hudson, but I instantly started craving them.

I grew up on hard-shells beginning at the now-shuttered Abe’s Oyster House in Atlantic City. Years later, I dove into them at The Crab Claw on Maryland’s Eastern Shore where we sat outside at newspaper-covered picnic tables and cracked away.

I wonder why there are so few places in the city that offer this delicacy. Blue crab is so sweet and satisfying. Many people believe eating hard-shells is too much effort for too little reward. I am not one of them.

I found my tasty reward at Anastasi Seafood in the Italian Market. I have not been to this retail shop/restaurant in years, but it has hard-shells, so off we went.

There are tables outside for those who enjoy dining al fresco, but we took seats at the bar because every table was taken.

One will not find a nicer staff anywhere. A glass of beer was in order, and since I was in the Italian Market, a pint of Peroni ($6) from Italy hit the spot. Edward sipped a Yard’s Pale Ale ($6), and our feast began.

The culinary gods were looking after us: Anastasi serves cherrystone clams ($1.25) each. We devoured two dozen of these meaty, freshly shucked beauties, nestled on a tray lined with small square ice cubes, which are among my favorite foods. Don’t forget to ask the server for oyster crackers and horseradish.

Soup on a warm summer night is a fine appetite stimulant. A cup of white chowder ($4.50) was made with crab and shrimp. The texture was perfect; some homemade chowders can be too thick and gloppy. This version was prepared with tiny squares of carrot that made it a bit sweet to my taste.

Hard-shell crabs (three for $15) can be ordered clean, dirty, with or without Old Bay seasoning. I like Old Bay, but I prefer a light hand. I decided to go classic: steamed crabs atop a garlic olive oil sauce.

A pile of napkins and lobster crackers for easy crabmeat extraction were in order. The first taste of this delicate, sweet crustacean was downright satisfying. The crabs were steamed beautifully and not one bit overcooked. Whoever was in charge of them knows how to cook crab. It was simply summer on a plate in South Philly.

A fried fish combination dinner, a favorite from childhood, is difficult to find on a restaurant menu. The Anastasi platter ($20) consisted of a large slice of fried Jersey flounder, shrimp, scallop, oyster and crab balls. Each piece of fish was free of grease and fried to a light golden brown. A sprinkling of salt and a squeeze of fresh lemon juice were required. Since tartar sauce and fried fish go so well, ask for it. Customers will get cocktail sauce, however. I found the tartar sauce a bit too sweet. The french fries were crisp and hot, but the coleslaw was a bit bland and needed more mayonnaise.

Summer is the season for fresh seafood. Anastasi is offering soft-shell crabs that have become very expensive in markets within the past few years. It also has specials such as halibut and a well-planned menu for all seafood lovers.

I know the craving for lobster will arrive soon. I will be off to Anastasi to enjoy.

Three-and-a-half tips of the toque to Anastasi Seafood. 

Anastasi Seafood

1101 S. Ninth St.

Contact the South Philly Review at

Add to favoritesAdd to Favorites PrintPrint Send to friendSend to Friend


Comments 1 - 1 of 1
Report Violation

1. Santiago said... on Jan 30, 2015 at 08:57PM

“I don't think i will ever eat seafood again after eating at this place twice. On my way home one night i had to pull the car over and vomit. The owner is a Sociopath. Sweet on the phone but so rude after you hand her your money. $15 for one imitation crab cake. Stale bread and roaches crawling during the night time on the seats. Don't believe me go there and find out. Pasta looks like something taking out of the trash can and put back on the plate. The crabs always look dead and taste bad when you cook them. Lets not forget how they're so overpriced. Nothing like the good old days where you could go out to some place and enjoy yourself. I don't know how they're still in business. They won't be around much longer with the way they do business and treat their customers.”


(HTML and URLs prohibited)

Related Content

Seafood valid
By Joseph Myers

Anthony D’Angelo strives to make the offerings at Ippolito’s Seafood , 1300 Dickinson St., reflections of current consumer awareness and interest. The 11-year owner is using his family’s 83-year history of selling quality products to make the location a contemporary force. Loyal patrons have responded by citing the Passyunk Square establishment for its seafood selection.


Blizzard Dream Food

Hungry Pigeon

The Olde Bar

Mustard Greens

Abe Fisher

Butcher and Singer

New Year Trends and Wishes